The gift that didn't give

As the only party leader in the debate unburdened by MLAs, the Greens' Jane Sterk should have been able to use legislators' lavish new compensation package against the Liberals and New Democrats. But, during tonight's debate, Ms. Sterk wasn't quite able to do so.

Her opportunity came when a Vernon mechanic posed this question to Liberal leader Gordon Campbell: "Why did politicians support a two percent wage increase for the workers and when it came time for themselves they voted a large wage increase as well as a gold-plated pension. Kind of puts them in the same league as the executives at the big banks at the U.S. with their huge bonuses as the company is sliding in the toilet. Why should anybody vote for any of the political parties. I don't see any integrity from the NDP or the Liberals."

"Obviously, none of us would want to hear that," responded Mr. Campbell, his expression a reflection of that fact. Nevertheless, the Liberal leader defended the pay-and-pension increase because he believes it's important to fairly remunerate those who "put their personal lives on hold" to become elected officials.

Mr. Campbell then tried to block whatever points Carole James hoped to score from the question by noting her party "voted against it. But they all made sure that they got the benefits from it" - a reference to the fact the New Democrat legislators have been donating their salary increases but enjoying their generous new pension plan.

But it was Ms. Sterk who really had an opportunity to score, distinguishing the Greens from the money-grubbing Liberals and New Democrats. This was her Gordon Wilson moment. But it passed Ms. Sterk by.

To be sure, the Green leader acknowledged she shared the mechanic's concerns "about the raises the MLAs gave to themselves on the excuse that that would encourage more competent people to enter the legislature."

"It isn't going to do that. It isn't doing that. The same people are running for the two parties. And they were paid that amount of money. They could have continued with the cost-of-living increases which was just as generous or more generous than most working people were given," she continued.

Ms. Sterk also said the salaries for the parties' political support staff were also a concern. But she then concluded with this comment: "personally I think that the raises were too high and we might even have to look at moving them back."

With nothing to lose and everything to gain, the Green leader could and should have had a stronger finish then that. But she didn't.

Leave a comment

Copyright © 2004 - Public Eye Mediaworks. Reproductions of any portion of this Website are permitted only with the expressed permission of Public Eye Mediaworks.
Canadian Web Hosting graciously provided by dotcanuck Web Services. Layout and graphics courtesy of Art Department Design.