
The president of the Canadian Association of Journalists is weighing-in on the controversial firing of Victoria News editor Keith Norbury, who was forced out after publishing a story about a cross-border used car shopper. In an interview this morning with Public Eye, Mary Agnes Welch said, "We don't know all the details of the relationship between the editor and the newspaper. There could have been exacerbating circumstances. But, if in fact, it was this story - and one angry advertiser - that led to the departure of the editor and possibly one of the senior reporters I think this really calls into question the credibility of the paper. And, if I were a reader, I would wonder how many stories got either spiked because of an advertiser complaint or downplayed or soften because somebody complained or because the paper was fearful of offending an advertiser. As a reader, I would really start to question the independence of the paper."
"It's really so petty in many ways," Ms. Welch added. "Newspapers are a business. We are, to some degree, at the mercy of advertisers. It's just really unfortunate that - over such a small story - the newspaper would apparently cave like that."
In an earlier interview with Public Eye, Vancouver Island News Group president Mark Warner confirmed Mr. Norbury's firing was, in part, connected to a complaint by Dave Wheaton Pontiac Buick GMC Ltd. dealer principal Dave Wheaton. Reporter Brennan Clarke, who wrote the offending article, resigned earlier last week. The Victoria News, which is owned by Black Press Ltd., is part of the Vancouver Island News Group.
Are any of the mainstream media breaking Omerta on this, or has the cone of silence descended as usual? Funny how any crack in the integrity of food/consumer product supply systems, health systems, etc. is headline news anywhere, whereas a flaw in the integrity of the information systems we rely on daily to keep tabs on everything else is generally taboo.
Sad and sordid as this story is, it's really just the logical outcome of the distorting effect that advertising - especially automobile advertising - has on newspapers. Look at any major daily paper on a Friday (the Vancouver Sun, for example). It'll have one - or maybe even two - sections devoted solely to automobiles. Is this because there's so much news about automobiles that a special section is required? No, it's because car dealerships advertise heavily on Fridays in order to entice people into their showrooms on Saturdays. And to justify all those ads, a few stories about automobiles (all positive of course - nothing about congestion, pollution or hit-and-runs) are thrown onto the front of the section.
The Victoria News may have overstepped the line, but it was a tenuous line in the first place.
According to the Wheaton website, Wheaton owns 17 dealerships in the Western Provinces. Obviously any sort of criticism from Dave Wheaton would carry a lot more weight than a single dealership in a single Black Press market.
Dawn uses the mafia term omerta, and I agree. There seems to be a code, not just among news managers and owners, but among reporters and pundits themselves, that they don't criticize one another, no matter what. And this is important because the Fifth Estate is the information channel we all rely on, ... whether we particularly feel like it or not!
Conservatives criticize government monopolies on the ground that citizens are left with no choice in service providers. The point has some validity, although it's hard to conceive of alternative providers of police, defence or highway services, except where this amounts to privatizing parts and pieces of an overall public system. However, it's curious that conservatives, in both the US and Canada, are reluctant to criticize the monopoly or near monopoly in the media industry. And just as curious that liberals and the left haven't been able to make a persuasive issue out of the situation.
Media omerta isn't quite true. A-Channel reported on this on their 6 and 11 pm newscasts Monday, and CBC Victoria discussed it Tuesday morning with a media professor. The Tyee also linked to Sean Holman's original story. But the Times Colonist will remain silent as they would look like big fat hypocrites. I'll be interested to see if (Black Press owned) Monday magazine tackles this one.
I left the newspaper business over fifteen years ago because they were more focused on keeping advertisers happy or promoting a publisher's pet projects than actually objective reporting. I see things haven't changed.
Allan Warnke
At the Rockpile
Bob Russell
Broken News
Creatures of Government
Fighting Words
From the Gallery
Letter from the Editor
Loose Lips
Off the Hill
Public Eye Radio
August 2007
July 2007
June 2007
May 2007
April 2007
March 2007
February 2007
January 2007
December 2006
November 2006
October 2006
September 2006
August 2006
July 2006
June 2006
May 2006
April 2006
March 2006
February 2006
January 2006
December 2005
November 2005
October 2005
September 2005
August 2005
July 2005
June 2005
February 2005
January 2005
December 2004
November 2004
October 2004
September 2004
August 2004
July 2004
June 2004
May 2004
Copyright © 2004-2006 Public Eye Mediaworks. Reproductions of any portion of this Website are permitted only with the expressed permission of Public Eye Mediaworks. Public Eye is graciously hosted by TransitionalMedia. Content management services courtesy of Ian King. Layout and graphics courtesy of Art Department Design, Victoria, BC.
This site is powered by Movable Type.