
On Monday, Vision Vancouver city councillor Heather Deal weighed in on parks board member Allan De Genova's caucus suspension saying, "It looks as if Sullivan and the NPA power-brokers are punishing one of their most popular representatives just for speaking his mind on an ethical question." At issue: a possible conflict between Heather Holden's role as a parks board chair and her job at the Vancouver Aquarium. But, coincidentally, a number of city watchers have raised eyebrows about Ms. Deal's clean air advocacy and her employment with the David Suzuki Foundation.
At a recent Greater Vancouver Regional District meeting, Ms. Deal presented a motion that would have reversed the board's decision to extend the AirCare testing exemption for newer cars. The councillor brought forward that motion on behalf of the district's environment committee, of which she is a member. But some found it odd when climate change analyst Nicholas Heap made a presentation at that same meeting, supporting the motion. After all, Ms. Deal and Mr. Heap are colleagues at the foundation - where she works as a marine researcher.
Asked for comment, the councillor said "I was a full-time biologist with the Suzuki Foundation. I now work two mornings a week with them. I discussed it with people as to whether or not there was any conflict (in me bringing forward the motion) because the Suzuki Foundation was also making a presentation. And everyone around me said, 'Don't be silly.' I don't work in (the climate change) part of the foundation at all. I work on the fish side." Ms. Deal added the foundation approached her about making a presentation at the meeting only after the district's environment committee had approved its AirCare motion.
apparently she was late for the meeting too.
How are the two situations comparable?
Holden works for the aquarium, which hopes to expand its operations, a step made easier by the parks board's decision not to require a citywide plebiscite first. Deal works for an advocacy organization. Sure, her employers wouldn't be unhappy if she helps implement a policy change they've been asking for, but the most that the DSF would get out of it is some good PR, something they can put in their next annual report and say "See, look what we helped to do."
If there's any pecuniary benefit to DSF (i.e., through increased donations by people who're impressed by their lobbying of the GVRD), it's a hell of a lot less direct than the pecuniary benefit to the aquarium.
I agree with obscurantist, it's a real stretch to describe this as a conflict of interest. There needs to be some monetary benefit involved that has the ability to alter the stance a public official would take on an issue for their to be a genuine conflict of interest.
But I have found that in the past ten or so years that the term conflict of interest has been downgraded to a catch-all phrase meaning any kind of linkage that one doesn't care for.
The NPA, hit with an internal split, seeks to divert attention by manufacturing a story about something completely unrelated.
Looks like Mayor Sam Harper's, er, Sullivan's media Shock Troops are once again demonstrating their finely honed spin prowess.
Too bad the only one biting is Holman. But then again, who else can you depend upon to bite even when there isn't a worm on the hook?
yeah Sean, I'm trying to see the story here but I can't... I think grouse is right on this one.
Agree there Holman is biting.
"De Genova.. you've made it this far.."
"Stay with what you have or choose from the other civic parties.."
"Deal or no Deal....?"
At the Rockpile
Broken News
Creatures of Government
Fighting Words
From the Gallery
Letter from the Editor
Loose Lips
Off the Hill
Public Eye Radio
December 2006
November 2006
October 2006
September 2006
August 2006
July 2006
June 2006
May 2006
April 2006
March 2006
February 2006
January 2006
December 2005
November 2005
October 2005
September 2005
August 2005
July 2005
June 2005
February 2005
January 2005
December 2004
November 2004
October 2004
September 2004
August 2004
July 2004
June 2004
May 2004
Copyright © 2004-2006 Public Eye Mediaworks. Reproductions of any portion of this Website are permitted only with the expressed permission of Public Eye Mediaworks. Public Eye is graciously hosted by TransitionalMedia. Content management services courtesy of Ian King. Layout and graphics courtesy of Art Department Design, Victoria, BC.
This site is powered by Movable Type.