Fleming discloses student election shenanigans

Last week, Province columnist Michael Smyth, acting on anonymous phone calls, reported Victoria-Hillside election candidate Rob Fleming had been a member of the International Socialists. But, in a candid interview with Public Eye, Mr. Fleming says he thinks British Columbians have a right to know about the other skeleton in his closet: while running to become the University of Victoria Students' Society's finance director eight years ago, he impersonated an election official to get his opponents' signs torn down.

Here's what happened: by the last week of the 1997 student election, the race between the right-leaning Putting Students First slate and the left-leaning A Strong Student Voice slate had turned downright nasty. Mr. Fleming, a member of the student voice slate, says the left's signs were being destroyed on a nightly basis. And his team suspected deputy chief electoral officer was bending the rules in favour of the right.

Of particular concern: the placement of two banners hanging from the second floor of the Commons Block building promoting right-wing candidates Kelly Sundberg and Ian Flemmington - banners which student voice members thought violated election rules. But when they weren't removed, Mr. Fleming left a message on the university janitorial service's answering machine late one night, claiming to be an electoral officer and ordering the signs torn down.

"It was poor judgement," the now Victoria city councillor said. "And we felt that others were getting away with things and not being punished. So we took the law into our own hands. It was a very vigilante-type action. And it made things worse in the campaign. And it was stupid."

Mr. Fleming was disqualified for his actions but the left-wing dominated student council overturned that decision and he won the election, earning him a $19,000 per year job. The whole affair was reported in The Martlet, the Times Colonist and on CH Television.

Reflecting on the experience, Mr. Fleming said, "There was a lot of pranks and trickery going on," during the election. "And I made the mistake - and it's personally embarassing to me - of getting down in the gutter and abandoning sportsmanship against my opponents. It was a bit of a wake-up call for me personally in terms of the way I've approached politics since."

"I think you should acknowledge your opponents strengths and be generous and try and bring some honour to the process because that's what the people want. And if you act with bad will and intentions you reap what you sow...And what I learned is that the high road is the best road to travel in politics. And that's something that was an absolute operating principle during my recent campaign in Victoria-Hillside."

Mr. Fleming added that, after the incident, "I worked very hard at repairing relationships and worked very hard at the students' society to put it in good shape. So that even people who felt bitter that I had won election would at least respect the work I did. And I think I achieved that."


Good for Rob for coming forward with details his enemies might otherwise try and use against him and proactively thwarting them.

Anyone who's been involved in student politics at UVic (myself included) knows how easy it is to get wrapped up in the emotion and seemingly life-or-death importance of otherwise benign student elections.

Everyone has skeletons in their closet, and by proactively revealing this youthful indiscretion Rob ensures that his opponents are shown to be silly and petty if they try to bring it up.

Everyone has skeletons in their closet, and by proactivly revealing this youthful indiscretion Rob ensures that his opponents are shown to be silly and petty if they try to bring it up.

If Rob Fleming honestly believes what he says, then he is an asset to any party. I don't support his party but I'd like to see more people in government, no matter what their political strip, who practice what he preaches.

Heck Rob has been impersonating a politician for years. I don't see what the problem is/was!

This was a story was reported on, not really a secret. Good move on Flemming's part to get it out now. Still this is alot different than someone in the Premier's office acting like a "Peter".


Actually Peter was acting more like a Dick.

Any political campaign manager worth their salt knows that if you are going out at night to tear down signs, you don't tear down your opponent's signs -- you tear down your own -- and you don't get caught.

That's hilarious! Good for him; now the whole province can enjoy this, not just him and his friends...

Is he going to disclose the accusations of racism by Sonia Manak next?

may i suggest,,
that rob dust off that old resume, he will need it, once elected to the ledge,with suprisingly, a
small list of paybacks,it,s no more a-kisssing.
my prediction is the writers in victoria will call rob fleming boring.
bottomline though the ndp should build around this person,.

Leave a comment

Copyright © 2004 - Public Eye Mediaworks. Reproductions of any portion of this Website are permitted only with the expressed permission of Public Eye Mediaworks.
Canadian Web Hosting graciously provided by dotcanuck Web Services. Layout and graphics courtesy of Art Department Design.